 |
LGBT Pop and Tob Notes
These speaker’s notes match the corresponding
numbered slides in the LGBT POPULATIONS AND TOBACCO PowerPoint
presentation. Speakers who use this CD-ROM should print out
(or copy and paste) these notes, then edit them to suit time
constraints, audience needs, and personal style.
1. To contact Perry Stevens, call 901.218.7600
or write to PerryStevens487@msn.com.
He can also be reached through the Tobacco Technical Assistance
Consortium at Emory University in Atlanta, GA.
The author would like to thank Lisa Carlson and
Pamela Redmon of TTAC, Scout of the Fenway Institute, Linda
Block of the CDC Office on Smoking and Health, Pat Dunn of
Amphora Consulting, and Ruth Malone and Naphtali Offen of
the University of California-San Francisco for their guidance,
suggestions, edits, and invaluable input.
2. This presentation will look first at
what we know about tobacco use prevalence among Lesbian/Gay/Bisexual/Transgender
populations. Then we’ll focus on ways the tobacco industry
targets LGBT—through advertisements, sponsorships, and
corporate giving. Then we’ll examine the common myths
about tobacco and tobacco use that are held by many LGBT people.
We’ll look at some communication strategies for reaching
LGBT populations in the hope that we can reduce LGBT tobacco
use prevalence. At the end of the presentation are some resources
for LGBT tobacco use cessation, other LGBT tobacco control
resources, and some suggested action steps for making inroads
into the LGBT community.
3. The research that exists on tobacco use
among adults consistently shows a higher tobacco use prevalence
among lesbian/gay/bisexual/transgender populations than among
the general population. Though, to be accurate, most of the
research has been conducted among gay men and lesbians, with
scant research directed toward bisexuals and no research conducted
on transgender individuals. In a review of the known literature,
led by scientists at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control’s
Office on Smoking and Health and the University of California-San
Francisco, the numbers for smoking among LGBT youth ranged
from 38 to 59%, compared to a prevalence among the total youth
population ranging from 28 to 35%. Adult LGBT smoking rates
went as high as 50% according to some studies, compared to
28% among the general population of adults.
Source: American Journal of Preventive Medicine.
AJPM (21) 2. Ryan, Wortley, Easton, Pederson, Greenwood. “Smoking
Among Lesbians, Gays, Bisexuals: A Review of the Literature,
2001.
4. In an online poll conducted by the Internet
research group Harris Interactive and the gay-owned Witeck-Combs
Communications, results indicated that smoking prevalence
among LGBT populations is higher than other adults, in this
case 36% of self-identified smokers were LGBT compared to
only 25% of all adults. IMPORTANT NOTE TO PRESENTER:
This was a relatively small study conducted via Internet with
self-reported results, so it is not definitive, though it
does demonstrate a need for further research. Source: Harris
Interactive and Witeck Combs Communications poll.
May 14, 2001
| (NOTE
TO SPEAKER: The info below is FYI…feel free to use
as needed in the presentation) Other info:
GayHealth.com
http://www.gayhealth.com
(search for “Tobacco and Witeck”)
Survey released May 14, 2001 conducted by Harris Interactive
and Witeck Combs Communications. About 36 percent of
adults aged 18 and over who self-identify as lesbian,
gay, bisexual and transgender report that they smoke
cigarettes, compared with 25 percent of all adults,
according to the survey results. Seventy-five percent
of LGBT smokers say they have tried to give it up, compared
with 80 percent of all adults.
http://www.hivandhepatitis.com/health/121399.html
In a new study published in the December issue of the
American Journal of Public Health, the UCSF team reports
48 percent of gay men in the research survey smoked,
compared to an overall rate of 27 percent among U.S.
men. The study involved 2,600 self-identified gay or
bisexual men.
In addition to smoking prevalence, the study looked
at related behavioral, socio-economic, and health factors,
such as heavy drinking, frequenting gay bars, educational
background, and HIV status. The study was designed and
conducted by a research team from the UCSF Center for
AIDS Prevention Studies.
"This study yielded findings that showed, at least
in the early 1990s, about half of all gay men smoked
tobacco, and one possible interpretation is that current
tobacco prevention efforts designed for men in general
are failing gay men," said Ron Stall, PhD, lead
author and associate professor with UCSF CAPS.
"Even among the youngest participants in our study-ages
18 to 24-the smoking prevalence rate was 50 percent,
which suggests that smoking will be a danger to gay
men's health for many, many more years. The time has
now come to consider how we can design tobacco prevention
and cessation campaigns that would work specifically
for gay men," Stall added.
If future public health interventions are to be effective,
additional research is needed on a number of issues
particular to gay men who smoke, including psycho-social
factors such as the effect of the AIDS epidemic, noted
co-author Thomas J. Coates, PhD, director of UCSF CAPS
and executive director of the UCSF AIDS Research Institute.
"In this study alone, we saw a correlation between
smoking and those who experienced a loss to AIDS, so
we know a targeted message must integrate several complicated
issues," he said. He also emphasized the need to
include smoking prevention and cessation, HIV prevention,
and substance use issues into a comprehensive gay and
lesbian health agenda.
Gay and bisexual men taking part in the study were
recruited in Portland, Ore., and Tucson, Ariz., in 1992.
Ranging in age from 18 to about 65 years, participants
represented white, African American, Hispanic, Native
American, and Asian/Pacific Islander ethnic groups.
Their information was compared with 1994 epidemiological
data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
for the general male population.
http://www.glbthealth.org/sabuse.html
Of respondents to the 1985 National Lesbian Health
Care Survey:
- 30% smoke daily
- 11% smoke occasionally
- 26% were worried about their tobacco usage
- According to the 1988 National Lesbian Survey, the
rate of smoking among lesbians increases with age,
whereas rates of smoking among women in the general
population decline with age
|
5. The Harris/Witeck-Combs marketing survey
shows that gays and lesbians are more aware of the risks associated
with smoking than the adult population as a whole. A total
of 96 percent of LGBT smokers say smoking increases their
risk of lung cancer and heart disease, and 96 percent say
it will probably shorten their lives. Whereas, 88 percent
of all adult smokers believe smoking increases risk of lung
cancer and 84 percent think it increases risk of heart disease.
Only 80 percent of all adults believe smoking will probably
shorten their lives. This indicates that LGBT smokers are
getting the public health messages, but these messages aren’t
as effective with LGBT. Why is that? It might have something
to do with the specific ways the tobacco industry markets
its products to LGBT populations. IMPORTANT NOTE TO
PRESENTER: This was a relatively small study conducted
via Internet with self-reported results, so it is not definitive,
though it does demonstrate a need for further research. Source:
Harris Interactive/Witeck Combs poll. 5.14.01
6. The Pulse is the first-ever LGBT Health Assessment conducted
in the Kansas City, Missouri metro area. Researchers conducted
surveys at Gay Pride and other community events in 2003 and
published the results in April 2004. The 100 page health report
is the product of a partnership between the Lesbian and Gay
Community Center of Kansas City and the Kansas City, Missouri,
Health Department. The survey of about 1100 LGB people showed
a high rate of tobacco use, especially cigarette use among
gay men and lesbians, with bisexual prevalence even higher
(though the sample size of bisexuals was quite small compared
to the other groups.)
Research Published April
3, 2004…obtained online from
http://www.take-the-pulse.org
Contact: William D. Snook, M.S. Ed.,
Program Manager
Division of Health Education
and Health Communication
Kansas City, MO Health Department
Phone: (816) 513-6274
Fax: (816) 513-6295
Bill
Snook
7. The Pulse looked at a number of health issues including
tobacco use. The evidence gathered in Kansas City indicates
that smoking prevalence is significantly higher in lesbian
and gay populations compared to the rest of the adult population.
LGBT prevalence (at 38.4 percent) is 10-12 percent higher
than in the general population of both Kansas City and the
state of Missouri…and it’s 15 percent higher than
the national average for adults.
8. We’ve discussed the problem of high tobacco use
prevalence among lesbians and gays, and the obvious question
is, why are LGBT rates so high? Much of the answer comes from
specific tobacco industry marketing toward LGBT populations.
So how does the industry accomplish that?
9. Gays and lesbians are targeted by the industry in a number
of ways. Direct advertising (ads in LGBT publications; direct
mail); indirect advertising (ads in mainstream publications
with a disproportionately high percentage of LGBT readers,
such as Details, GQ, Entertainment Weekly); event sponsorships
(such as Out On Film—the Atlanta gay and lesbian film
festival; the Miss Gay U-S-A At-Large Pageant); and outreach
efforts and community promotions (HIV/AIDS causes; LGBT bar
nights featuring cigarette brands). These sponsorships are
an important piece of the tobacco industry’s multi-billion
dollar per year marketing costs. (The tobacco industry spent
$9.57 Billion in marketing in the year 2000—that amounts
to more than $26 million every single day. Source:
Federal Trade Commission, Cigarette Report, 2000. Obtained
from Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids at http://www.tobaccofreekids.org)
10. The tobacco industry has employed an
interesting method for directly advertising to gays and lesbians…and
it has done so in a way that allows the industry to avoid
criticism for doing it. Here’s an example. These ads
are virtually identical. The one on the left features a man
looking at a woman in the distance reclining in the pool.
This ad ran in Penthouse, Madamoiselle, and Interview magazines
in 1995. The ad on the right is exactly the same, except another
man has been added between the first two figures. This ad
ran in OUT magazine at the same time in 1995. It’s not
clear whether the man in front is checking out the woman in
the pool or the other man perched on the side of the pool.
(Parliament advertisements obtained from http://www.pmadarchive.com,
doc#s 2061031517 and 2061031505)
As Kevin Goebel pointed out earlier in a 1994 article in
the journal Tobacco Control, these are examples of “coded
ads.” By rendering the “straight” ad sexually
ambiguous through the addition of a third person, the ad suddenly
resonates with a gay audience. But because the woman is still
in the picture, the industry can deny it is marketing directly
to gays. Source: K. Goebel. Lesbians and Gays Face
Tobacco Targeting. Tobacco Control 1994;3, 65-67.
11. Parliament ads have been used in the
same way to appeal to lesbians. The image on the right appeared
in Rolling Stone magazine in 1995. The same ad—plus
another woman—appeared the same year in Out magazine.
One media consultant writes that the industry intentionally
creates ads that are ambiguous in order to avoid a backlash
from both the political right and left. Extreme conservatives
don’t want the industry validating gays and lesbians
through advertising dollars (and, in fact, have organized
boycotts of companies that do market to LGBT communities).
On the other hand, LGBT public health advocates don’t
want to see gays and lesbians lured into smoking out of loyalty
to tobacco companies that pump money into the community. Through
use of ads such as these, the tobacco industry attempts to
thwart opposition from both camps. (Parliament ads
obtained from http://www.pmadarchives.com, doc#s 2061031553
and 2061032419)
12. This montage of Virginia Slims ads from
1994 appeared in Kevin Goebel’s Tobacco Control article.
This ad campaign subtly—or not so subtly—targeted
lesbians. While the woman holding the fishing rod has a ‘butch’
stance, the women in the middle are obviously having an intimate
moment of some kind, and the text in the right-most ad is
undoubtedly a coded message to gays, reading “If you
always follow the straight and narrow you’ll never know
what’s around the corner.” The vast majority of
straight people would never pick up on the lesbian overtones.
Source: K. Goebel. Lesbians and Gays Face
Tobacco Targeting. Tobacco Control 1994;3, 65-67.
13. RJ Reynolds now heavily promotes its
Camel brands to LGBT audiences through two-page advertisements
in The Advocate, like this one published in early February
2003. It features a handsome bartender (who just might be
checking out that musician reflected in the mirror behind
him, or perhaps that other gentleman sitting and having a
drink that we can see through the other mirror.)
14. The Camel campaign also features an
attractive female model looking directly at the reader. This
ad ran in The Advocate February 18, 2003
15. This American Spirit cigarette ad appeared
in at least two issues of The Advocate in the Fall of 2002.
The Advocate buy is the only one for this RJ Reynolds brand
known for this particular ad. The triangle shape is not a
mistake—Its intention is to make a connection between
the lesbian/gay readership and American Spirit through use
of the gay pride triangle symbol. This is a subtle move by
the tobacco company. Most heterosexuals would never connect
the triangle shape with gay pride, so the resulting stealth
marketing is highly targeted and flies under the mainstream
radar.
American Spirit also heavily advertised in Details magazine
in late 2002 and early 2003. But in Details, which caters
to a high percentage of gay readers but is not technically
a ‘gay’ magazine, the ads avoided the triangle
shape.
16. Girlfriends is a national magazine for
lesbians. Until recently, the magazine refused to accept tobacco
advertising, but in the face of a financial crunch, the editor
relented and began accepting cigarette ads. They are now featured
prominently, like this example of a Kamel ad on the inside
front cover directly across from the table of contents (Girlfriends,
V6n12, June 2000). Like many publications targeting a niche
audience, including newspapers and magazines for African-Americans
and Latinos, the acceptance of tobacco ads is often the difference
between publishing and going out of business. Like Girlfriends,
most of these publications end up running the ads.
17. Philip Morris doesn’t blatantly
target gays in its U.S. advertising, but it has no qualms
about doing it in Europe. This 2000 ad for PM’s Nobel
brand was obtained from Mike Wilke’s Commercial Closet
website, an amazing repository of LGBT ads from a variety
of companies that promote a staggering array tobacco and other
products.
(Nobel ad obtained from http://www.commercialcloset.org)
18. Another Philip Morris brand sold in
Europe….this very gay ad is from 2001. Again,
thanks to Mike Wilke’s Commercial Closet
(http://www.commercialcloset.org)
19. The more overt tobacco advertisements
commonly published in Europe are not confined to targeting
gay men. This ad for the British American Tobacco brand Lucky
Strikes featuring two beautiful lesbians ran in European magazines
in 2000.
(Source: Wilke’s Commercial Closet
http://www.commercialcloset.org)
20. In another example of advertising directed
at LGBT populations outside the U.S., this ad for Buz cigarettes
appeared in Canada in 2000. It includes two young women sharing
a cigarette, apparently after having sex. Along with the young,
same-sex models, notice the illicit drug vernacular (‘Catch
a BUZ’).
(Buz ad obtained from Tobacco Control V9n1, p103,
March 2000)
21. This interesting looking ring is very
similar to those worn by many lesbian or gay couples to signify
their commitment to one another. Rings very much like this
one are sometimes exchanged in a ceremony referred to as a
Holy Union.
22. But in this case, the ring is not a
‘holy union band’…It’s a ‘cool’
KOOL ring. This ad appeared in the men’s fashion and
entertainment magazine DETAILS in October 2002. The added
detail of this ring is likely to have broad appeal to lesbians
and gays.
And what of the brand KOOL itself? Some studies indicate
LGBT smokers are more likely to smoke mentholated cigarettes
than heterosexuals. KOOL mentholated cigarettes are heavy
advertisers in alternative newspapers and glossy magazines
(like Details) with a high percentage of gay readership. This
particular ad was one of several KOOL ads appearing in the
October 2002 issue of Details. The magazine is not an overtly
gay publication, but recent articles include features on Gay
Republicans, gay TIVO programming, and a highly publicized
speculative essay about whether or not baseball player Mike
Piazza is gay.
23. One means of indirect marketing by the
tobacco industry to GLBT populations is through theater playbills
like these. The industry knows that 71% of gays attend live
theater compared to only 21% of straights (American
Demographics magazine March 1998). In the summer
of 2000 these were three of the shows playing in New York.
A two page ad for Parliament cigarettes appeared in the centerfold
of each one of these playbills. The industry also places ads
in other arts publications, and in these, too, a disproportionately
high number of gays see them. Gays are five times more likely
to attend a classical music concert and four times more likely
to attend a dance performance than straight people. (same
source as above)
24. An element of LGBT tobacco use that
is harder to pin down includes a constant media bombardment
of images glamorizing smoking. These images were obtained
from the Internet. (from top left clockwise: Matthew McConaughey;
Leonardo DiCaprio; Queen Latifah; Johnny Depp, Brad Pitt;
and Mark Wahlberg). Celebrities using tobacco—including
celebrities with an obviously gay sensibility—reinforces
the marketing to LGBT populations by the industry. The images
on this slide and the following two slides were gleaned from
tobacco fetish sites from all over the Internet. Most of these
sites go on to include much more sexually graphic pictures,
mostly amateur porn shots that highlight tobacco use. Some
photos are manipulated using PhotoShop and other graphics
programs to turn PG- and R-rated celebrity smoking shots into
X-rated shots.
25. More images pulled from gay smoking
fetish websites. (from left: Vin Diesel, Matthew McConaughey,
John Travolta, Brad Pitt)
26. More images from gay smoking fetish
websites (from left: Kiefer Sutherland; Brad Pitt, Mark Wahlberg)
27. Some of the previous images were pulled
from these websites and others. As you can see, the issue
of smoking as a sexual fetish needs some attention. It’s
important to note that this is NOT a uniquely lesbian and
gay phenomenon. There are thousands of smoking fetish sites
for both straight & gay and male & female smokers,
yet very little attention is given to this problem by those
of us in tobacco control.
28. One form of indirect advertising may
or may not be intentional, but it shouldn’t be overlooked.
Tobacco products are often used as symbols for masculinity,
wealth, and having a good time. This ad (in the November 12,
2002 issue of The Advocate) for the International Gay/Lesbian
Travel Association features three guys vacationing at a Las
Vegas casino. The copy reads’ “Jeffrey, Paul,
and Tony…Hometown..Chelsea, NY..Favorite thing about
New York New York: Cocktails!” And when these Chelsea
boys have a good time, they smoke big fat cigars. All three
of them have one. Did IGLTA intentionally put the cigars in
the models’ hands? Sure they did. Every element of a
national advertisement is studied. But the question is, why?
When we can address that, we may have some clues about effective
interventions targeting gay men.
29. This Lucky Strike ad appeared in a tobacco-sponsored
GLAAD event program (GLAAD is the Gay & Lesbian Alliance
Against Defamation organization dedicated to stamping out
offensive and derogatory images of LGBT in the media).
The text of the ad says, “Whenever someone yells, ‘Dude,
that’s so gay,’ we’ll be there.” Advertisements
like this are a reminder from the industry that they ‘have
our back’ and will be a true friend. The underlying
message is, “We’re loyal to you, so you be loyal
to us.” This is an extremely effective marketing tool
for targeting LGBT people because research indicates that
lesbians and gays are particularly brand-loyal. This is because
images of—and messages to—lesbians and gays have
been relatively absent from advertising until very recently,
so when they do appear, LGBT tend to remember them.
30. The marriage of cigarette advertising
and gay culture can be seen in this T-shirt advertisement
for Café Lafitte….a gay club in New Orleans.
The logo even includes the “warning” that’s
really an invitation (“May be habit forming. Contains
sultry men & intoxicating music.”) Obtained from
the National Association of LGBT Community Centers website
at http://www.lgbtcenters.org/anti-tobaccomedia.html
July 5, 2002
31. The tobacco industry works hard to win
loyalty from gays and lesbians, and one of the ways it does
this is by trumpeting all the great things it does for the
community. This ad appeared in PRIDE.02, The Magazine for
Gay Pride in the USA, Special 5th Anniversary edition (It’s
a glossy, huge 280-page magazine sold nationally with pictures
and stories from every major Gay Pride parade in the country.)
The full page ad touts Philip Morris’ commitment to
diversity, saying it’s a strength to the company. It
goes on to boast about being one of the largest corporate
contributors to the fight against HIV/AIDS. It says that managers
are held accountable at Philip Morris for the diversity of
their departments and business partners. Philip Morris goes
on to remind us that it offers domestic partner benefits and
has maintained sexual orientation anti-discrimination and
anti-harassment policies for the past 16 years. It supports
LGBT employee organizations and trains all its employees in
diversity awareness education programs. All this information
is important to LGBT people who have long struggled to gain
this type of corporate recognition. The result is increased
corporate and brand loyalty toward Philip Morris and its products.
32. The industry is certainly generous—not
only to LGBT causes but to causes important to other high
risk and minority populations as well. The reason we all know
that is because they’re paying for us to hear how generous
they are. In 1999, Philip Morris gave away $60 million dollars,
from helping to feed the homeless to AIDS charities and other
organizations in need….but then they spent $100 million
telling us how generous they are. From the article: “The
contributions provide Philip Morris with a veneer of respectability,
but critics worry that by carefully choosing the recipients
of million-dollar grants the company is quietly buying the
neutrality and, in some cases, the grudging support of important
parts of the American body politic.”
Source: Robert Dreyfuss, “Philip Morris
Money” The American Prospect v11 n10 March 27, 2000
33. This picture appeared in a 2000 issue
of XY, a glossy magazine targeting gay male teens. XY is one
of the few LGBT publications with a policy against accepting
tobacco or alcohol ads. And in this issue the editors included
what they thought was a good tobacco control message. The
information in the text conveys the message that nonsmokers
have more sex and better sex than smokers. But the picture
accompanying this information would seem to convey another
message entirely---It seems to say that smoking IS sex. If
you were flipping through this magazine and stumbled across
this page, would you be more likely to remember the text or
the image accompanying it? Despite the good intentions behind
the information, this is an example of ways even a good idea
can backfire. And this image is another example of the so-called
‘sexualization’ of tobacco seen frequently in
LGBT media. One problem is that depicting smoking in this
way may actually trigger cravings and smoking behavior, and
that’s why this kind of image is so dangerous.
34. We’ve talked about ways the industry
markets to LGBT populations, but just why are these groups
so vulnerable to the marketing techniques described?
35. There are many misconceptions held by
lesbians and gays about cigarettes, and being aware of these
misconceptions will help those of us in tobacco control better
understand the challenges of making progress in these communities.
Some LGBT people view cigarettes as a psychological or social
crutch (“It gives me something to do with my hands at
the bar.” As we saw earlier, tobacco use is a sexual
fetish for some LGBT people, but no matter why a person uses
tobacco, everyone risks the health consequences the accompany
tobacco addiction. LGBT brand loyalty stems from feelings
of loyalty some LGBT people toward the tobacco industry because
of the generous charitable giving to LGBT causes. Tobacco
ads appear with great frequency in LGBT publications because
those publications often need the ad revenue to stay in business.
And, finally, there are relatively few tobacco control efforts
directed at LGBT, so progress in reducing LGBT tobacco use
prevalence has been slow.
36. One of the most common myths about tobacco
among LGBT populations is also one of the reasons why LGBT
are so vulnerable to tobacco industry marketing: The myth
that tobacco use is equated with masculinity. This is an issue
not only for some gay men who wish to present themselves in
a ‘masculine’ light, but also for some lesbians
who believe cigarette use can make them more ‘butch.’
Along those same lines, there’s a misconception that
using tobacco will make you sexy.
For some LGBT people, using tobacco is perceived as a sign
of their independence or rebellion from the norm. Others diminish
the health effects of tobacco use, especially in light of
the more dramatic effect of AIDS and the fear of anti-gay
violence or discrimination that still exists. Others rationalize
their tobacco use by saying it’s good to ‘give
back’ to the tobacco companies that advertise in the
LGBT press. And still others believe that smoking and other
tobacco use is simply part of being gay.
37. We’ve discussed the problem of
industry marketing to gays and lesbians and the reasons GLBT
populations are especially vulnerable to tobacco marketing
messages…so what can we do to fix it?
38. Author Grant Lukenbill, an expert in
LGBT marketing and author of the book UNTOLD MILLIONS, has
written that LGBT consumers tend to respond best to marketing
efforts that focus on individuality.
They also respond to messages that meet a need for association
and recognizes the LGBT community (for example, a LGBT consumer
might respond to a message that’s run in a LGBT publication
because of knowledge that it was intended for his/her community.
This corporate recognition and acknowledgement carries a lot
of weight among populations who have been shunned or ignored
by advertisers in the past).
LGBT people also respond to messages that search out and
celebrate life’s diversity; that reduce stress; and
that address skepticism and mistrust.
Adapted from UNTOLD MILLIONS. Grant Lukenbill, 1999,
Haworth Press Inc.pp129-130
39. There are simple ways for tweaking our
mainstream tobacco control programs so that they have more
appeal to lesbians and gays. These strategies include implementing
a non-discrimination policy that covers LGBT and posting it
in a visible location; using paid advertising in LGBT publications
when possible; including job opportunities at your organization
in LGBT publications; and, adding LGBT publications to your
organization’s media distribution list Adapted
from UNTOLD MILLIONS. Grant Lukenbill, 1999, Haworth Press
Inc.
40. Other strategies for positioning your
programs to appeal to the LGBT community is to use inclusive
language in all your marketing communications; form alliances
with LGBT organizations to offer tobacco control education
and to raise your organization’s profile among lesbians
and gays. (Effective ways to forge alliances include involving
LGBT people in program design and planning, and by partnering
and sub-contracting with LGBT organizations for funding opportunities.)
And additional research indicates that LGBT mobilize when
they feel they’re being manipulated or exploited. This
is the same rationale behind the American Legacy Foundation’s
successful truth ads aimed at young people. Showing the LGBT
community how the tobacco industry has marketed to them while
at the same time holding them in contempt is important information.
Legacy, in conjunction with the Gay & Lesbian Medical
Association, has a website devoted to the most blatant example
of this: Project SCUM (the acronym stands for Sub-Culture
Urban Marketing) and it was the name of a RJ Reynolds initiative
to increase sales in San Francisco’s predominantly gay
Castro district as well as San Francisco’s Tenderloin
area, where the homeless were targeted. Project SCUM came
to light when the tobacco industry was legally forced to share
its internal documents. The URL for the Legacy website appears
in the resources slide at the end of this presentation.
Parts of this slide adapted from UNTOLD MILLIONS.
Grant Lukenbill, 1999, Haworth Press Inc.
41. Here’s an example of a statewide
campaign designed to reach lesbian and gay smokers in California.
The Billy DeFrank Lesbian and Gay Community Center along with
the Center of Orange County were granted funds from the American
Legacy Foundation to launch the “Cigarettes are my greatest
enemy” campaign in February 2003. The campaign used
LGBT people from California who were willing to talk about
their triumphs over adversity, and how that gives them strength
to stop using tobacco.
The original news release marking the launch of this campaign—
Campaign to Focus on the Lesbian, Gay,
Bisexual, and Transgender Communities SAN JOSE, Calif.,
Feb. 27 /PRNewswire/ -- Because tobacco-related lung cancer
causes more deaths in the LGBT community than AIDS, drugs,
breast cancer, or gay bashing combined, The Billy DeFrank
Lesbian & Gay Community Center, The Center OC and
American Legacy Foundation have sponsored a statewide
social marketing campaign that launches on February 27,
2003. Renowned social marketing firm Better World Advertising
(http://www.socialmarketing.com)
created the media campaign that highlights the experiences
of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people who
are dealing with their tobacco addictions. The campaign
features images of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender
people who have triumphed over adversities like alcohol
and drug addiction, homelessness, breast cancer, and other
life threatening situations and are using this strength
to quit smoking. Capitalizing on these individual successes,
this campaign aims at inspiring other lesbian, gay, bisexual,
and transgender people to quit smoking. Taglines will
include messages such as: "I didn't survive gay bashing
to die from lung cancer." Lesbian, gay, bisexual,
and transgender people smoke at significantly higher rates
than the general population. This higher smoking prevalence
can be attributed to issues including: homophobia; the
high numbers of targeted tobacco advertisements in lesbian,
gay, bisexual, and transgender publications; and tobacco
industry sponsorships of community events. The American
Legacy Foundation is a national, independent, public health
foundation dedicated to building a world where anyone
can quit. One of American Legacy's goals is to eliminate
disparities in access to tobacco prevention and cessation
services. For more information about the American Legacy
Foundation, visit http://www.americanlegacy.org.
The mission of the Billy DeFrank Lesbian and Gay Community
Center is to strengthen communities by developing diverse
resources that empower lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender
people and their allies. The mission of The Center OC
is to provide services to ensure the physical, psychological,
and social well being of the gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender,
and HIV/AIDS affected community. The goal of Better World
Advertising is to improve the quality of human life by
designing and implementing strategies that achieve high
levels of community education, self-efficacy, and beneficial
behavior change. SOURCE Better World Advertising
Web Site: http://www.socialmarketing.com
|
42. More images in the “Cigarettes
are my greatest enemy” media campaign launched by the
Billy DeFrank Lesbian and Gay Community Center and The Center
of Orange County, with funds from the American Legacy Foundation.
43. More images in the “Cigarettes
are my greatest enemy” media campaign.
44. If we in tobacco control want to reach
LGBT populations, we must let it be known that LGBT people
are welcome as visitors, members, and leaders of our organizations.
A welcoming environment can include posters or pictures depicting
LGBT in your hallways, having LGBT representatives on your
boards and advisory groups, or something as simple as including
a rainbow sticker somewhere on your window or waiting room.
On another front, money talks—even a little bit of
paid advertising in LGBT publications can have a significant
impact. As mentioned previously, there has been a great absence
of LGBT recognition in marketing until very recently. Gays
and lesbians are conscious of which organizations and products
are advertised directly to them, and that’s one of the
reasons LGBT populations are so receptive to overtures from
the tobacco industry. We need to take the same approach as
the industry in recognizing this population, and we can do
that through paid advertising; and also by having a presence
at Gay Pride events—either by entering a float or staffing
an information booth.
45. By adding LGBT media outlets to your
press list, you’ll increase your chances of getting
earned media in the gay press, and that will help you raise
your profile among LGBT.
When spokespeople from your organization are making speeches
or talking to the press, add lesbians and gays to your list
of disparate populations. (“Racial and ethnic minorities;
women; lower socioeconomic status; lesbians and gays; blue-collar
workers, etc”). And when possible, go to where lesbians
and gays use tobacco, by initiating educational outreach at
LGBT bars, clubs, and other venues.
46. If we use information like we’ve
discussed today, and incorporate LGBT elements into our tobacco
control programs, perhaps images like this one—a gay
person with a cigarette—will stay relegated to the past
where they belong.
47. The Last Drag began in 1992 and is the
nation’s first and longest-lasting cessation program
for LGBT people.
University of California San Francisco Quit Site for LGBT
Smokers
http://iquit.medschool.ucsf.edu
| In February 2004, researchers at the
University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) launched
iQuit—an Internet-based smoking cessation study
for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) smokers.
The one-year study will compare two Internet-based smoking
treatments: one that provides general information that
has been helpful in a variety of smoking treatment programs,
another that includes the general information plus information
and support designed especially for an LGBT audience.
For more information about this study, visit the iQuit
website at http://iquit.medschool.ucsf.edu. For questions,
please contact Anthony Taylor at taylora@itsa.ucsf.edu
or call toll free at 866-895-8050.
|
48. Tobacco Technical Assistance Consortium
LGBT Resources http://www.ttac.org/lgbt/index.html
(LGBT Tobacco Action Plan)
From adversary to target market: the ACT-UP boycott of Philip
Morris. Offen et al. Tob Control.2003; 12: 203-207
Gay tobacco ads come out of the closet. G. Yamey. BMJ, July
31, 2003; 327(7409): 296 – 296.
The Outing of Philip Morris: Advertising Tobacco to Gay Men.
Smith and Malone. June 2003, Vol 93, No. 6 American
Journal of Public Health, 2003-06-01
An analysis of tobacco industry marketing to lesbian, gay,
bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) populations: Strategies for
mainstream tobacco control and prevention. Stevens et al.
Health Promotion Practice, July 2004.
49. National Association of LGBT Community
Centers (NLGBTCC) http://www.lgbtcenters.org,
email: info@lgbtcenters.org
Gay and Lesbian Medical Association (GLMA) http://www.glma.org
phone: 415.255.4547
Gay American Smokeout http://www.gaysmokeout.net
phone: 206.769.8693
American Legacy Foundation—”Project SCUM”
http://www.projectscum.org
King County (Seattle area) GLBT Health Pages, Tobacco and
Smoking http://www.metrokc.gov/health/glbt/tobacco.htm
LGBT Tobacco Control Consortia (Los Angeles area)
http://www.smokingkills.org/WEB2/lgbt2.html
LLEGÓ--the National Latina/o Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual
& Transgender Organization http://www.llego.org
50. This listserv for tobacco control professionals
interested in LGBT tobacco control information can be joined
at:
http://groups.msn.com/LGBTTobaccoPreventionControl/messageboard
51. Little information has been published
about developing and implementing counter-marketing campaigns
targeting LGBT populations. But this 2003 publication from
the CDC’s Office on Smoking and Health, Designing
and Implementing an effective Tobacco Counter-Marketing Campaign,
provides a template for a more general campaign as well as
information about tailoring campaigns for specific populations.
For more information about this publication, call 800-CDC-1311
or write ccdinfo@cdc.gov
52. Gene Borio’s Tobacco.org site
http://www.tobacco.org
53. LGBT Populations and Tobacco Control
CD-ROM Resources
- Dreyfuss, R. Philip Morris Money. The American Prospect
V11n10, May 27, 2000
- Gay and Lesbian Medical Association (GLMA) and LGBT Health
Experts. The Healthy People 2010 Companion Document for
LGBT Health. San Francisco, CA: Gay and Lesbian Medical
Association, 2001. http://www.glma.org
- Goebel, K. Lesbians and Gays Face Tobacco Targeting. Tobacco
Control 1994;3, 65-67.
- Harris Interactive and Witeck-Combs Communications poll.
May 14, 2001
54. LGBT Populations and Tobacco Control
CD-ROM Resources
- Lukenbill, G. UNTOLD MILLIONS. 1999, Haworth Press Inc.
pp129-130
- Mike Wilke’s Commercial Closet http://www.commercialcloset.org
- National Association of LGBT Community Centers
http://www.lgbtcenters.org/anti-tobaccomedia.html
- Philip Morris Advertising Archive http://www.pmadarchive.com
- Ryan, H., et al. Smoking Among Lesbians, Gays, Bisexual:
A Review of the Literature. American Journal of Preventive
Medicine. AJPM (21), 2001.
- Tobacco Control V9n1, p103, Editorial. March 2000)
Back to LGBT Populations and Tobacco
2nd Edition
|
 |